Skip to content
NSW SelectiveYear 7 entry

Data reasoning in Selective Thinking Skills

Independent. Not affiliated with the NSW Department of Education.

Data reasoning means telling apart what a table or chart shows from what it proves. In Selective Thinking Skills, your child chooses the claim the numbers support and rejects claims that go further than the data.

Watch the full lessonPlay the preview

The full lesson is in the SelectiveReady app. A free account opens How and Why Authors Write; this lesson needs a paid plan.

Updated 16 October 2026 · Facts checked 12 October 2026

What Does the Data Tell Us? (lesson preview)

A short preview from the SelectiveReady lesson “What Does the Data Tell Us?”, on data reasoning for the NSW Selective test.

Published:

Read the video transcript

All right, let's bring in our next suspect, conclusion number two. This one is way bolder. It claims studying more causes better scores. Whoa, that's a huge claim, right? But the real question is, does our evidence actually back that up? Nope. This conclusion is way too strong. It falls right into that classic trap we just talked about, confusing correlation with causation. I mean, sure, the two things seem linked, but this chart doesn't prove that studying is the only reason for good scores. What about other stuff? Like how much sleep did they get? Or maybe they were already good at the subject. The chart doesn't say. So we absolutely cannot claim one causes the other.

What Does the Data Tell Us? is a full lesson in the SelectiveReady app.

A free account opens one lesson, How and Why Authors Write; the other lessons need a paid plan1SelectiveReady · 13 October 2026 · Published. Captions on the preview are in English and Chinese.

2

What will your child learn in this lesson?

Your child learns to read a chart like a detective reads a witness statement: carefully, and without believing more than it says. They'll be able to tell what data shows from what it proves, and spot a claim that goes too far.

The clip tests a bold claim about study hours and test scores, and finds it too strong. The full lesson adds the golden rule, three conclusions to judge and the most wanted list of traps.

3

How do data questions show up in Selective Thinking Skills?

Your child reads a small table or chart, then decides which statement is definitely true, could be true or cannot be true. The numbers are usually small, but the wording of each option matters.

The Thinking Skills testWhat it means for data
402NSW Education · 12 October 2026 · Published questions in 402NSW Education · 12 October 2026 · Published minutesRead the title and labels before the numbers
No calculator2NSW Education · 12 October 2026 · PublishedAny halving or adding is done by hand, on working paper
42NSW Education · 12 October 2026 · Published options per questionSort each option: shown, a leap, or against the data
The practice papers say there are no marks lost for incorrect answers3NSW Education · 13 October 2026 · PublishedA careful choice always beats a blank
4

What is data reasoning?

Data reasoning is deciding what a set of numbers really tells you. For a Year 6 child, that means reading tables and graphs, and judging which claims about them are fair.

The lesson's golden rule is the difference between a link and a cause. When two things rise together, that's a link, or correlation.

When one makes the other happen, that's a cause. A chart can show a link, but it rarely proves a cause.

Here is how the lesson judges three claims about one chart of study hours and test scores.

ClaimVerdictWhy
Students who study more tend to score higher.FairTend to describes the trend the chart shows
Studying more causes better scores.Too strongSleep or earlier skill could explain it too
Everyone who studies a lot will score highly.Not supportedA trend isn't a promise; some students won't fit it
5

What is the method for data questions?

Read what was measured, read what the question asks, then sort each option by how far it goes. Choose the claim that stays inside the data.

Shows or proves? A rising bar chart. Tends to: supported. Causes: too strong. Always: not supported.
  1. Read the labels

    What was counted, in whom, and when? Notice what the table doesn't include.

  2. Read the question's words

    Definitely true, best supported and cannot be true each ask for something different.

  3. Sort the options

    Is it shown in the data, a leap beyond it, or against it?

  4. Watch the strong words

    All, every, always, will and causes need more proof than a table gives. Tend to and most are safer.

6

What does a worked data question look like?

We made up this table and question to show the method.

DayWeatherDrinks sold at the canteen
MondayHot60
TuesdayMild35
WednesdayHot55
ThursdayCool20

Question: Which statement is best supported by the table?

OptionStatement
AHot weather makes every student buy a drink.
BMore drinks tended to be sold on warmer days that week.
CThe canteen will sell more drinks than this every hot day.
DMost students at the school bought a drink on Monday.
StepWhat your child does
Read the labelsFour days, the weather and drinks sold. Nothing on how many students there are.
Read the questionBest supported: the claim the table backs most safely.
Sort the optionsA says every and makes: too strong. C predicts every future day. D needs a number the table doesn't give.
ChooseB. Tended to matches the pattern across four days.
7

What mistake do children make with data?

The common mistake is picking a claim that sounds right instead of one the data supports. A trend becomes always, or a link becomes a cause.

TrapWhat it looks likeThe fix
Going beyond the dataA claim about people or days the table never coveredPoint to the row or bar that proves it
Tends to read as alwaysA pattern turned into a rule for everyoneKeep the word tend to unless every case fits
Forgetting outliersAssuming nobody breaks the patternRemember one student can study a lot and still score lower
Missing informationUsing numbers the table doesn't give, like class sizeAsk: is this column actually here?
8

Can my child try one on their own?

Here is a table question from our free Thinking Skills set. It asks which statement is definitely true.

Practice question · SEL-TS-TST-22

The table shows how many library books each of the four Year 6 classes at a school borrowed in Term 3.

ClassBooks borrowed
6A42
6B35
6C50
6D28

Based on the table, which statement is definitely true?

  1. A

    Class 6D borrowed exactly half as many books as Class 6C.

  2. B

    Class 6C borrowed more books than any other Year 6 class.

  3. C

    Class 6C has more students than any other Year 6 class.

  4. D

    Every student in Class 6B borrowed at least one book.

Show answer and explanation

Answer: B

Answer: B (Class 6C borrowed more books than any other Year 6 class.)

  1. 50 is the largest number in the table, so 6C borrowed more books than 6A, 6B or 6D.
  2. The table gives only the number of books for each class. It says nothing about how many students are in each class or who borrowed them.

Why the other options are wrong

  • A: Half of 50 is 25, and 6D borrowed 28, so this is false.
  • C: A class could borrow the most books without having the most students; the table does not give class sizes.
  • D: The table shows the class total only; some students in 6B might have borrowed several books and others none.
  1. Read the labels

    Each row is one class's total. There's nothing on class size or on individual students.

  2. Test B

    6C has the biggest number in the table, so it borrowed the most. The table shows it directly.

  3. Test C and D

    Class size and who did the borrowing aren't in the table, so neither is definite.

  4. Test A, then answer

    Halve 6C's total and compare it with 6D's: they don't match. The answer is B.

9

How can my child practise data reasoning at home?

Charts are everywhere, from weather maps to sports results. Short chats about them build the habit.

Shows or proves?

Pick a chart from the news or a sports page. Ask what it shows, then what it can't prove.

Run a family survey

Count something at home for a week, such as cups of tea or minutes outside. Then make fair and unfair claims about it.

Hunt the strong words

Find always, every and causes in adverts. Ask what proof each one would need.

10

Questions parents ask about data reasoning

What is correlation versus causation, in plain words?

Correlation means two things move together. Causation means one makes the other happen. Data often shows the first and rarely proves the second.

Does my child need to do sums?

Sometimes, but they're small. There's no calculator in any section, so your child works on paper. 2NSW Education · 12 October 2026 · Published

Which charts should my child practise reading?

Tables, bar charts, line graphs and pie charts are all worth practising, because each shows numbers in a different way.

Is the full lesson free?

A free account opens one lesson, How and Why Authors Write; the other lessons need a paid plan1SelectiveReady · 13 October 2026 · Published.

Sources and checks

  1. SelectiveReady

    SelectiveReady · Checked 13 October 2026

  2. Selective high school practice tests

    NSW Department of Education · Checked 12 October 2026 · Practice materials: personal or non-commercial use only; CC BY 4.0 does not apply (page notice). Page text: CC BY 4.0.

  3. Selective High School Placement Test, Thinking Skills Question Paper, Practice Test 1 (2026 entry practice tests, PDF)

    NSW Department of Education · Checked 13 October 2026 · Practice materials: personal or non-commercial use only; CC BY 4.0 does not apply (page notice). Quoted briefly with credit. Saved text: the cover-page instructions only; the question pages are not stored (W§3.22).

Found something that needs a correction? Tell us.